Got about halfway through this going to pick up dinner. Counting Sheep is the real standout. Love the album cover.
I would agree with this, it’s no coincidence that the further they’ve moved away from “shouty pop-punk” the better their music has been
Only song I don't love is Audrey Go Again but otherwise this is a ripper. Parts I love - Second verse on Never Said. Reminds me a lot of Such Gold - The pre chorus (?) in Some Girls. Honestly the pre chorus and the chorus are earworms - TELL ME WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYY - The bridge of Next Big Star. That back and forth is very Taking Back Sunday - The lead riff on I'll Be Around.
I'm not ready for that to be old enough (15 years!) for bands to be intentionally paying tribute to it, haha. I was thinking earlier today this would be a great rec to someone who enjoyed Proper Dose and were disappointed that TSSF regressed back to the mean instead of experimenting with their formula a little bit more. EDIT: also one more thing, I know we don't talk about them for obvious reasons, but there's some Better Off - Milk vibes on here too.
honestly the album is sorta muddy and a lot of it just runz together. like i’ve listened to it a handful of times, but aside from the singles nothing is really standing out as new. it’s a good take on what the giants have already done, but nothing genre breaking or defining. i’m at an 8.9\10 right now on it.
I’ve thought the same as you on that edit many times, even as the singles came out. It’s a shame that band went the way they did. Entirely unforced errors. Really loving that some of these songs are scratching that itch