Remove ads, unlock a dark mode theme, and get other perks by upgrading your account. Experience the website the way it's meant to be.

ANOHNI - HOPELESSNESS (May 6, 2016) Album • Page 3

Discussion in 'Music Forum' started by brandon_260, Mar 9, 2016.

  1. OhTheWater

    Let it run Supporter

    Not a fan of the Obama track but I really enjoy the rest. I "get" it, at the very least
     
  2. Garrett

    i tore a hole in the fabric of time Moderator

    After seeing a lot of buzz about this, and admittedly finding the Pitchfork review very curiosity inducing, I decided to give this another shot today after dismissing it after only hearing "Drone Bomb Me" and thinking this wasn't for me.

    I agree with @Kyle is hk that 4 Degrees and Why Did You Separate Me from the Earth? are the strongest tracks on this record because of the ability to balance the sound and the nuance of strong lyricism.

    The music of this album is immense, intriguing, and very satisfying. The risks, blending of styles, incorporating unexpected instruments, and things of that like are definitely top notch.

    I also don't find the on-the-nose lyrics to be off-putting or jarring as many of you seem to be suggesting. But, I also think the vocal delivery really, really hurts any sort of message she is trying to get across. I continuously found myself focusing more on the music than the lyrical message because many of the songs seemed to lose intelligibility in pronunciation.

    I don't buy into the argument that you have to read the lyrics along with a song to get its message. That's not how music works. If the message isn't clear in music without any additional work involved, the music isn't achieving as much as it could be.

    I was very intrigued by the circumstances and the message of this album. A transgender woman speaking out against violence, patriarchy, failed politicians, etc. was always going to be an interesting message that was important to check out. But now that I'm through with the album, I remember the music more than the message.

    Not to mention, "Obama" may be the worst track of 2016 thus far.
     
  3. Nick

    @fangclubb Prestigious

    I think the vocals are my favourite part.
     
  4. Chaplain Tappman

    Trusted Prestigious

    No one said you have to read the lyrics. If you are having trouble actually identifying the words in the songs I'm not sure what to tell you because I think you're the only one with that specific problem.
     
  5. Garrett

    i tore a hole in the fabric of time Moderator

    Multiple people in this thread have expressed needing to see the lyrics to help sort out their opinion of this album. Shrug.
     
  6. Chaplain Tappman

    Trusted Prestigious

    One person said he needed the lyrics to have a more informed opinion. That's not exactly an uncommon comment or one specific to this record. No one said they can't understand her and I find her to be extremely easy to understand honestly.
     
    Wharf Rat likes this.
  7. Kyle is hk

    Not Kyle Shanahan Prestigious

    So my question now is, would 4 Degrees be improved if it replaced the "four degrees" in the chorus with just straight up "global warming?" (syllable count aside). Both make the same bold, important, clear point. The latter does it it in the more jarring "attention-throttling" way most of you prefer. Is that preferable to the more appealing (imo) "four degrees" since it's more explicit?

    I hate to keep harping on the same point, I hope I'm not coming off as combative I just think it's an interesting discussion. I want to make sure my point is NOT that the message should be toned down, but the words more skillfully crafted.
     
    Garrett L. likes this.
  8. Nick

    @fangclubb Prestigious

    There's room for both styles of lyrics imo.
     
    brandon_260 and Chaplain Tappman like this.
  9. Wharf Rat

    I know a little something you won't ever know Prestigious

    I basically disagree completely. Don't find anything unintelligible and I'm not sure what the solution would be for the other problem. Make less interesting music so the lyrics are the only memorable thing? The message has definitely been the most enduring thing for me so
     
  10. Wharf Rat

    I know a little something you won't ever know Prestigious

    Yeah I find her extremely easy to understand
     
  11. algae

    Regular Prestigious

    I guess I shouldn't be surprised but you probably don't need to be criticizing the lyrics unless you're actually directly involved with the issues being addressed.
     
  12. Wharf Rat

    I know a little something you won't ever know Prestigious

    Well to be fair the content isn't what's being criticized. And also she's not directly involved in at least one of the major themes herself (drones), so
     
  13. algae

    Regular Prestigious

    Calling it "too on the nose" is criticizing the content. I know that's why I'm saying if say someone who has been affected by drones criticized the lyrics, it would actually carry some weight so
     
    Wharf Rat likes this.
  14. Nick

    @fangclubb Prestigious

    The first time I listened to Drone Bomb Me I thought the lyrical style was weird and a little different to styles that I am more used to but I think the straightforwardness of the lyrics and the delivery enhances the meaning behind them in a pull no punches way. You can very clearly hear her pain and anguish behind the words and I think abstracting that would take away from the gut punch of this record. Just my two cents tho.
     
  15. TheWater(s)

    Kiss The Sky Prestigious

    The thing about this record is it's really good. The lyrics being "jarring" or whatever is a good thing because it brings more attention to the message.
     
  16. brandon_260

    Trusted Prestigious

    It's been like 3 days and I'm already tired of people's hot takes on this album.

    Also, why is Obama the go to track to hate? It's so ominous
     
    TheWater(s) and Wharf Rat like this.
  17. Kyle is hk

    Not Kyle Shanahan Prestigious

    Can you elaborate on this? Because I feel the themes on this album are pretty universal to all types of people? I can't criticize songs about climate change, american imperialism, or drones?
     
  18. VanMastaIteHab

    Trusted Prestigious

    I have mixed feelings about this, but it's hard to ignore that some of these songs are really beautiful.

    Why did you separate me from the earth is definitely my favorite.
     
  19. Joel

    Trusted Prestigious

    The lyrics are far from intelligible, I only said I wanted to see the lyrics because I didnt catch everything the first time through

    It's beautiful, bought it today and feel like ppl should support this
     
  20. algae

    Regular Prestigious

    Might have phrased a little oddly, I think she's addressing a lot of these issues in a way that only someone who feels very disfranchised can. I haven't listened enough to really form a complete opinion on the politics in this and the perspectives its using but at the very least I think calling it "too direct" when it's positioning itself as a record about extremely violent, and personal experiences is strange.

    This is to say that while you have knowledge of drones, again can't get into the politics of the song just yet, but ANOHNI is adopting the perspective of someone who is being attacked by drones. Calling this too direct is missing the point of the narrative entirely. This is especially disrespectful for me when ANOHNI is addressing things that she is actually very directly affected by like patriarchal violence; to call her lyrics about that "too blunt" seems to dismiss the urgency of her words. She's trying to convey a message as simply and directly as possible, that seems imperative for the listener to understand her/for social progress/for her own life and for the lives of the voices she is embodying
     
  21. Dominick

    Prestigious Prestigious

    I love this album. 8.5/10

    From its content to its expression in music, it was perfectly executed. I think people need to think of art as the process by which individuals attempt to use their subjective expressions to map for themselves and for others their world, their expreriences and juxtapose them to dominant cultural representations, and to a lesser or greater degree, some people are successful. I think this was a rousing success; the value isn't necessarily in a marginalized person producing as such, but in their ability to draw in the materials of the world, such as drone bombing and the shared experienced of being targeted, to produce a cultural artifact that makes those experiences haunt you in a manner of speaking. Anyway, I'll stop being so effusive. The album is really good is what I'm saying.
     
  22. brandon_260

    Trusted Prestigious

    yo i just discovered this

     
  23. sdnyjns

    I am not a robot

    Was referred to this album by a friend. I've listened to it twice today and both times I fell more in love with it. It's my first time experiencing Anohni and I'm just blown away by her voice and the production work on here.
     
  24. cwhit

    still emperor emo Prestigious

    fallen for this lately
     
  25. brandon_260

    Trusted Prestigious

    Emphasis on late