Alkaline Trio Band • Page 185

Thought I was in the Bad Opinions thread reading that ranking. Wow.

 

Good Mourning
Maybe I’ll Catch Fire
From Here to Infirmary
Crimson
Remains
Goddamnit
Is This Thing Cursed?
Alkaline Trio
My Shame Is True
Agony & Irony
This Addiction

 

From Here to Infirmary
Goddamnit
Maybe I’ll Catch Fire
Good Mourning
Crimson
Is This Thing Cursed?
My Shame Is True
Agony & Irony
This Addiction

 

OK, so that's exactly how I'd rank them, except MICF and FHTI fluctuate between spots 2 and 3 depending on the day. And having Cursed at 6 isn't an indication that it's bad as much as evidence of how solid the top half of their catalog is.

 

Agreed about Cursed! If Dan was batting 1000 on that album, it’d definitely be a little higher for me

 

Crimson
From Here to Infirmary
Good Mourning
Maybe I’ll Catch Fire

Agony & Irony
This Addiction
My Shame Is True
Is This Thing Cursed?
Goddamnit

 

Good Mourning
Agony & Irony
From Here To Infirmary
My Shame Is True/Broken Wing EP
Crimson
Maybe I’ll Catch Fire
Is This Thing Cursed?
Goddamnit
This Addiction

If we can’t count the Broken Wing EP then I probably put Crimson above it.

also if S/T counts, I probably slide it in there right around Crimson.

 

Crimson
From Here to Infirmary
My Shame is True
Maybe I’ll Catch Fire
Agony and Irony
Good Mourning
Godamnit
Is this thing Cursed?
This addiction

 

I have no problem with most of this list, especially the top 3 (and id put crimson higher).

 

From Here To Infirmary
Good Mourning
Is This Thing Cursed
Crimson
Maybe I'll Catch Fire
Goddamnit
Agony and Irony
My Shame Is True
This Addiction

 

I actually had Crimson above GM and FHTI but the latter two have grown more on me in recent years.

 

Goddamnit is pretty high for me, cause despite being so scrappy and technically not as good, I just LOVE the almost off-the-rails feel it has.

 

Good Mourning
Goddamnit
Crimson
From Here To Infirmary
Maybe I'll Catch Fire
Is This Thing Cursed
My Shame Is True
Agony and Irony
This Addiction

 

Some of my absolute favourite Trio songs are bsides and the Hot Water Music split.

 

Their songs on the HWM split up there with their best for sure. The One Man Army split not quite as strong.

 

Same. I always have to include Remains in my album rankings because of that.

 

Remains and the S/T comp of all the early stuff have all their best songs for the most part

 

I hate not counting Remains and s/t in my rankings lol. S/t was the 2nd one I bought after Infirmary and had no idea for awhile it wasn't a proper album haha.

 

Seems like something for Asian man ?

 

Maybe they're gonna release the next album through them? Team up with their heart&skull?

 

So Trio or solo?

 

Probably solo unless Trio got dropped by Epitaph which I’m pretty sure isn’t the case?

 

I’ll take Skiba solo as long as it’s not Blink182 any day!

 

Epitaph never hesitates to band put their own artists solo records out. Mike could just be there hanging out or working with his friends.