Alkaline Trio Band • Page 178

New song or existing song?

 

I posted it in a spoiler before that post in case anybody wants to be surprised

 

Good Mourning
Is This Thing Cursed?
Agony & Irony
From Here To Infirmary
Crimson
My Shame Is True
Remains
Maybe I’ll Catch Fire
This Addiction
Alkaline Trio
Goddammit

I can listen to every single album front to back no problem. It’s a really strong discography from gothic blink-182. I also think Agony & Irony has the best production out of all their albums. It’s not even produced by Jerry Finn and I hold it in such high regard. It’s up there with TOYPAJ for me in regards to production. It’s amazing, timeless, and beautiful.

 

Skiba's raspy vocals (pre-throat operation?) on Good Mourning really are something. I think they make that my fave of theirs.

 

I fucking adore his vocals on that record.

 

I feel like I’d have a hard time ranking Alk3 records.

 

Good Mourning
Remains
Maybe I'll Catch Fire
Crimson
From Here to Infirmary
Goddamnit
Is This Thing Cursed?
Alkaline Trio
Agony and Irony
My Shame is True
This Addiction

 

Good Mourning
Remains
From Here to Infirmary
Goddamnit
Maybe I'll Catch Fire
Crimson
Alkaline Trio
Is This Thing Cursed?
Agony and Irony
My Shame is True
This Addiction

 

Good Mourning
From Here To Infirmary
Crimson
Is This Thing Cursed?
Agony & Irony
My Shame Is True
Maybe I’ll Catch Fire
Remains
This Addiction
Goddammit
Alkaline Trio

 

From Here To Infirmary
Crimson
Is This Thing Cursed?
My Shame Is True

the rest in whatever order

 

I just ranked ETID albums, I'm not doing another ranking this week lol

 

Seeing This Addiction so low hurts my feelings

 

I can't imagine having it anywhere other than last and I don't think it's a bad album

 

Good Mourning
Goddamnit
Maybe I’ll Catch Fire
Crimson
From Here To Infirmary
Is This Thing Cursed?
My Shame Is True
Agony and Irony
This Addiction

Can’t include Remains or S/T as they’re compilations and the quality of each varies quite a bit.

 

I don’t think Good Mourning sounds as good as some of their albums. Just listened to A&I and Good Mourning and will probably register to a few more of their records to see I a nature ranking comes together.

Remains may have some of my favourite Alk3 songs, but it is hard to rank compilations.

 

Good Mourning the goat duh

 

Idk, but the opening scene to the high school in the new Scream movie had me all in the feels.

 

I keep spinning back to Dan’s new Dear Darkness album singles so far.

 

Agony & Irony
My Shame Is True
Is This Thing Cursed?
Good Mourning
From Here to Infirmary
^ I always come back to these

Crimson
Remains
Maybe I'll Catch Fire
This Addiction
^ I rarely listen through these, just a handful of songs from each

Alkaline Trio
Goddamnit
^ I never listen to anything from these records

 

This Addiction is one of my faves I think. The title track, Dead On The Floor and American Scream are great.

I'm gonna have to listen to their discography this weekend now.

 

The lack of love for the early material on here astounds me. Perhaps it’s an age thing.

I’m mid 30s and love all the early stuff. It’s the later records which to me are very hit and miss (with more miss sadly).

 

Good Mourning
From Here to Infirmary
Maybe I'll Catch Fire
Goddamnit
Crimson
Is This Thing Cursed?
My Shame Is True
Agony & Irony
This Addiction

For me there's a couple of good songs on my bottom three, but the drop-off on those releases as whole albums is significant.

 

I’m 35 and although the early stuff is what I grew up on in my teenage years, I prefer a lot of their other material more.

Goodbye Forever and Radio are still my favorite songs from them and what got me into them, but I can’t help but feel like I did most of my growing up with Crimson, Agony, Addiction, Shame, and Cursed.

The Past Live performances do remind me how special their earlier stuff is though. Especially Catch Fire.

 

I have heard that Brazil has cool asses

 

I’ll attempt a ranking later…have to think about where the last two fit in for me