or just start from the beginning, they have four albums, it's not like it's that much of a time commitment
Crisis is probably the most accessible, but .44 Caliber Love Letter is such a distinct and special opener that I can’t imagine starting anywhere else than the self titled.
I always go chronologically with an established band I'm wanting to properly check out and give a go, because I can see how they've progressed, changed, and evolved which also gives me a better sense of how other fans feel if I want to discuss them. But, if you want to go from accessible/popular to the more experimental then I'd say Crisis > Watch Out! > Old Crows/Young Cardinals > S/T > Dog's Blood. Then the Death Letter EP which is basically some of their songs (mostly from Old Crows/Young Cardinals) reworked.
skip the self-titled at first, start with Watch Out! then work your way chronologically. if you're still hungry for more engage with the self-titled, but I don't really recommend that record.
All their albums are pretty different from one another, so there’s a good chance if one doesn’t click with you the next one might.
I'm already thinking about a possible setlist if they open for UO lol. Open with Season of the Flood(maybe trimming the opening for times sake). Then after a little excessive guitar feedback blast into Drunks, Lovers, Sinners, and Saints. Don't let me down random message board rumors! I need this.
Last time I was this surprised was that one (or two) days that saw Thrice and Thursday going on hiatus on one side and Refused and At The Drive-In announcing their reunions on the other.
Really hope the guys are the new support for Underoath. I need to see them and I can't afford the time and money to get to So What? fest
instead of going to Furnace Fest I've decided I'm going to follow AOF around the US for a few dates of their tour if they announce one