A Perfect Circle - Eat The Elephant (April 20, 2018) Album • Page 10

I found this to be a meandering, boring mess

 

All I see online is how awful this album is but I finally gave it a go and I love it. His voice is phenomenal on this.

 

Negativity speaks louder then positivity imo

 

Haven’t checked any other sites/reviews. It’s not going to top their other albums, but as a reunion album it checks all my boxes.

 

I implore you to re visit it a couple more times

 

I've seen a lot of 3-4 out of 10. Mostly saying it is a "get off my lawn" type album if that makes sense.

 

Yea the songs I've seen people who don't really like it actually like (Hourglass, Feathers) might be my least favorites on it strangely enough. If nothing else this will be quite an album to discuss over time and get reactions.

 

I think I really love this but I have no idea. By and Down the River is a standout to me, oddly enough so is Fish. Maynard's voice is incredible, though I must say there are a few weaker lyrics. Overall I think I really enjoy it. I feel like a month from now I'll be totally in love.

Semi-related, but I've been listening to the indie exclusive a bunch and the white vinyl w/white packaging looks pretty cool.

 

Cannot remember the last time I heard Maynard's voice on a live proshot.

 

what’s up with the creepy Spotify vids lol

 

I picked this up on vinyl today when I was in town shopping, that artwork is somehow even worse in real life. Anyways I'm still loving this album a hell of lot and haven't stopped playing it all week.

 

Hahaha

 

Yeah definitely don’t ever want to listen to this album every again now we know Maynard is a piece of shit

 

I think we knew that before all of this, but point taken

 

we been knew

 

That story came out like a month after the album came out...

 

Billy released a solo album today, which I was completely unaware of. I remember loving the Ashes Divide album back in the day, and some songs are still in my rotation so I'm looking forward to checking this out.

Judging from this interview, it's supposed to be more electronic leaning.

edit: So it's more of a 80s new wave record with gothic influences here and there, pretty much a departure from what he's done prior. That plus the fact he vocally sounds completely different made for quite a jarring listen. I'm into it and I'm going to revisit throughout the year though.