Round of 8: (3) The Smashing Pumpkins - Mellon Collie vs. (27) Weezer - Weezer (Blue) Bracket

Round four is here. The final eight albums. What album will come out on top?

NOTICE: PLEASE DO NOT VOTE UNLESS YOU'VE HEARD BOTH ALBUMS. STOP DOING THIS SHIT.

For this matchup, we start with:

(3) The Smashing Pumpkins - Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness

vs.

(27) Weezer - Weezer (The Blue Album)

 

remember these will be up until Sundays from now on

 

it'll be a fitting end to have all three jimmy albums lose to Weezer, the much better band, so let's get through this matchup.

 

Show me on the doll where Jim Adkins hurt you

 

Pumpkins probably my favorite album left

 

i like the band a lot lol it's yall that are hurting me

 

Clarity is the Mellon collie of emo so I guess it’s fitting they both get trounced by a much worse album

 

y'all talk way worse about weezer daily than i do about JEW and i'm the crazy one lol

 

How is Clarity the Mellon Collie of emo

 

Pumpkins all the way. Weezer have never written a single song I love as much as "1979" and "Tonight, Tonight"

 

if it were siamese dream, my vote would go the other way. mellon collie is fine.

 

Blue is great, and might even get more play for me than Mellon Collie, but I’m more impressed by Mellon Collie as an album. Went with the Pumpkins.

 

Im just saying things

 

Finally, I might say Weezer.

 

lmaooo lets go

 

10 perfect power pop songs or a double album with a few great singles and a TON of filler. Easy choice.

 

Gotta go with Blue.

 

The Pumpkins have to go.

 

Voting for the perfect power-pop album on this one.

 

Mellon Collie pretty easily for me. Pinkerton would have a shot, but I still think I go MC. Bodies? Muzzle? Tonight Tonight? 1979??? As much as I love the Weez, I think it's pretty clear. MCIS is a masterpiece, unrivaled by anything else the band has done or anything that their peers attempted. My love for it only grows as I get older. Mayonaise is their best song tho.

 

I went with Mellon Collie, but damn this was the toughest round for me.

 

TON of filler? This album has like a 95% batting range. The only possible "meh" songs are We Only Come Out At Night and Lily My One And Only. There are multiple b-sides alone that could have easily taken the place of album tracks.

 

Blue is top 2 or 3 ever for me, MCIS is top 15ish. I wouldn't blame anyone for voting the latter on it being a bigger swing. I also probably have 1979 as the best song between them. But I'm goin =w=

 

Mellon Collie

 

Pumpkins but expecting them to lose