Round of 32 (Old Comedies): It's Always Sunny vs. South Park

One is a comedy about awful adults. One is a comedy about awful children. Which will you choose?

 

South Park changed television forever in a lot of ways. It's not always great, but when it hits, it's nearly unbeatable.

 

Haven't really liked South Park since I hit my teens. Sunny for sure.

 

I really don't like South Park so that's an easy one

 

I think this will be a tight one, but ultimately think SP will win out. SP wore on me really quickly, but there are also some just downright terrible episodes of IAS. my vote is still IASIP.

 

First ten seasons of South Park are excellent, there’s some great IASIP episodes but it doesn’t come close to South Park’s consistency for so long. Now if we’re talking South Park just the last 5 or so years it probably wouldn’t make the bracket.

 

It’s Always Sunny, easily.

 

South Park. Peak South Park is GOAT status

 

Always Sunny and it's not close for me. The Gang Beats Boggs a top 5 episode of anything

 

South Park is better at its best but worse at its worst. Sunny was consistently great for 6 years then hit a huge hiccup and has been inconsistent for what is now half their run.

 

I'd argue that sunny has been more consistent over their run than south Park.

 

I've tried to get into It's Always Sunny multiple times and it never takes. South Park is a shell of itself now but every once in a while it shines bright.

 

A little surprised to see this so lopsided

 

This is crazy. They’re both good, but the best South Park is transcendent

 

im kind of shocked this is as much of a blowout as it is but the right show is winning

 

i wish tetra not liking sunny was more surprising to me than it is

 

South Park is probably the show I have stuck with the longest in my life. Easy pick for me

 

The characters are like the worst parts of Seinfeld. They stretch believability far past its breaking point.

 

so does the best of curb

 

The best parts of Curb are when they address real-world issues and our absurd adherence to traditions that don't make sense. Curb has been guilty of being too ridiculous at times.

 

This is the hardest one by far but south park.

 

I’m not as crazy about some of the most recent Sunny seasons as a lot of people around here are, but South Park has been trash for like 10 years. Even recently threw on a few classic ones for old times sake and after 3 shows decided it was better off left to memory

 

I haven't watched or cared about South Park in over a decade now but during its peak it was pretty much everything IASIP constantly tries to be