The Pie Wars

what is the best pie?

even tho I consider Cheesecake to be a pie, we're not going to include it, as to give the other pies a fighting chance

 

Chick fil A for sure

Edit: wrong thread sorry

 

careful

 

choosing between pecan and key lime was hard but I went for pecan because you can have chocolate pecan pie which is amazing, all key lime pie is pretty much the same and great

 

That doesn’t make any sense

 

No strawberry rhubarb so the actual best pie isn't on here so now I need to consider the second best.

 

pecan pie is a journey every time, will it be good or bad no way to know for sure until you take a bite

 

you get like 8 choices and strawberry rhubarb wasn't exactly at the top of the list

sorry

 

Why do you need your dessert to be a goosebumps choose-you-own-path novel?

 

I assume strawberry rhubarb was left off to give the other pies a fighting chance. Strawberry rhubarb is selfless like that.

 

pecan is top three pies for me

really good pecan pie is a transcendent experience

 

because my life is very boring unlike yours

 

You don’t know that. I could just be one of the most prolific, detailed story tellers of our generation.

 

I voted for cherry but all pies are good.

 

yes, all pies are good

that's the central thesis of the thread

 

Fuck may*

 

Is French silk the same as chocolate cream? Because that’s my favorite other than maybe banoffee but that’s not really a standard one so I get why it’s not on the list

 

PUMPKIN

 

Does cream pie count?

 

I agree

 

you got this, Key Lime

 

i’d go with coconut cream pie, but since that’s not an option gimme some french silk