2025 MLB Season Baseball • Page 455

Was this song playing the last month for Cleveland?

 

he won't win it but he should

 

No...he shouldn't.

 

Raleigh is also excellent at pitch framing and is probably also going to win a gold glove again. What he's done for the Mariners is truly insane, and even more insane when you consider his position.

 

I do look forward to every NYY fan being personally offended and slighted forever if Judge ends up not winning it though, just another piece for them to add to their ever suffering tortured fanbase

 

generally i don't care who wins this race but you truly cannot use bwar to evaluate catchers

 

hate to see a bright young pitcher become washed so early into his career

 

It is genuinely absurd how good Skenes has been to start his career.

 

I don't care if he's a catcher, Judge is actually playing hurt the last month and when your average and on base are 100 points higher than the competition it's almost impossible to not give it him and they will not based on history.

 

it is certainly not impossible lol

 

Simply don't be hurt

 

“I don’t care if he’s a catcher” is a dumb thing to say about playing one of the most difficult positions that has gotten even more difficult with the pitch clock changes and having to frame masterfully

 

Like just say batting is all that matters, why even play a position just let them hit the ball, that’s the only measure that you care about!

 

Can you imagine Major League Tee-Ball

 

they've provided nearly the same value to their teams. half a win difference in fwar is too close to be taken as law, which then pivots us to narrative, which Raleigh obviously has

if Trout can lose despite being way better than triple crown winner Miggy, then Raleigh can win despite being at worst half a win less valuable than Judge

 

narrative is way more fun

everyone knows judge is good. he's on HOF track. it's ok if he doesn't win another mvp

 

Sure good enough reason....he's won plenty in past. He's gotta share!

 

that's not what I said, is it?

 

I like how you ignore the rest of the points brought against it and instead just go right to this lol

 

there are so many bad MVP voting cases even in recent history and this simply wouldn't be one of them. both are worthy winners imo

edit: to your point, i agree narrative is fun

 

if this means so much to you where ya been all season pal

 

yeah like, as a chiefs fan, shouldn't mahomes have every mvp and andy reid have every coach of the year? or should tom brady have had every mvp?

if you think bigger picture how is this season gonna be remembered:

aaron judge was good (again) and the yankees made the playoffs

OR

cal put up historic numbers on their own and for his position and his team won their division for the first time in a quarter century?

 

There’s a chance the tigers make the playoffs on a 12 game losing streak lmao

 

just like the dodgers heyyy

 

dodgers gotta win today cause the next three games are against the mariners and big dumper is going to ruin them

unless they can just keep praying padres lose for them