2024-2025 NFL Season II Pink Pony Club [ARCHIVED] Football • Page 1783

but you won’t send me money, interesting..

 

I’m a yes on Brees, Fitz, Witten probably and I think that’s it from this group

 

Todd Gurley is a throwback

 

Gurley would be the youngest poster in this thread, which is crazy

 

I am not older than Todd Gurley

 

point still stands. boomer ass thread

 

sorry but bijan is a fraud

 

you could veryyyyyyyyyy easily convince me Frank Gore and Greg Olsen should get in first ballot but, yeah those first 3 are the locks.

 

Greg should get in much because of what Fox did to him imo

 

They were on my shortlist but I was just kinda like..meh. Especially with some of the non first balloters who are still waiting.

 

Man I don’t think Greg Olsen was HOF good

 

Julian Edelman is the fun one that can make people get into fights so I support that

 

I guess Rivers can too but meh

 

i think the NFL HOF these days is much like the NBAs where its really just the Hall Of Great Career, i think Olsen will get in at some point but likely not first ballot.

 

Imagine the essays Randall could write if Julian Edelman is inducted before Fred Taylor

 

Looking at his numbers he had 3 great seasons and pretty meh otherwise. He’s 89th all time in yards right now. Not in my HOF!!!

 

I say neither but Edelman is more likely

 

Yeah I loved Greg Olsen but I don't think he's a HOFer at all

 

COULD write?

 

Brees and Fitz are locks (which also pushes some other guys like Eli down another year or two at least). Most of the rest of that list is probably a no. Edelman lacks the longevity and numbers. Witten is probably a guy that gets in after several years, but it wouldnt make me blink if he didnt. I like most of those O-lineman, but, especially interior line is gonna have a hard ass time getting in

 

He's not on my "impossible" list out of those but he is below my line of approval or whatever who the fuck cares I'm Dustin

 

Why is it called the hall of fame when it’s more like a room?

 

I think Eli should get in

 

Makes you think

 

I think 6 of the first 7 here (no Edelman) actually have HOF cases