2024-2025 NFL Season II Pink Pony Club [ARCHIVED] Football • Page 1755

Ultimately, I don't care enough about it. He will eventually get in, but Eli not being a first ballot Hall of Famer *is* some bullshit.

 

Murph can't stop catching L's

 

Eli is not first ballot and if he never got in it would be fine


*ducks*

 

I don’t care about it one way or other. The whole hall of fame thing

 

name 5

 

Eli is such a strange case imo. He was basically average except for two iconic and legitimately clutch and awesome playoff runs. If first ballot is supposed to signify the elite of the elite he probably doesn’t deserve it

 

he should be in man idk what to tell ya

 

KOC winning COTY is crazy

 

YOU CANT SPELL ELITE WITHOUT



oh whatever

 

Eli more like pee-li

 

no, crazy is dave canales not winning it

 

I am declaring myself officially mad online. No Vinatieri is a joke

 

correct

 

reid should win it every year until he retires

 

I do recall going on record saying this class was so stacked i wouldnt be shocked if eli didnt get in even though i thought he deserved it but yes no vinatieri is incredibly sus.

 

Eli should’ve gotten into even if Sean is purposely misrepresenting what I said about Canales

 

Maybe kickers were just so bad this year that it ruined the good name of any good kicker ever

 

Chris Boswell erasure

 

Apparently they’ve changed the rules a bit so we’re going to see smaller classes like this moving forward. Gonna be a lot of guys waiting

 

The logic is sound I admit

 

@theagentcoma

 

joshy deserved it

 

I don’t really mind the process described, which means my issue is with the voters themselves lol

 

Sterling Sharpe would’ve broken so many records if he never got hurt and got to play with prime Favre

well deserved