2019-2020 NFL Season Thread [ARCHIVED] Football • Page 1897

Cool so now you have shit for RBs and that’s now not a good example of what we are talking about hahaha

 

Give Dave a madden team with a really crappy rb

 

Oh right, I forgot when one player leaves there is a leage rule mandating I'm not allowed to replace them. My bad lol

 

Taysom Hill can be my starting RB idgaf haha

 

Like OH ID PAY $6M FOR THE SAINTS RBs

Oh yeah? And get (squints) a 30+ year old Latavous Murray who wasn’t even a starter in his prime?

 

I forgot that it’s easy to just replace Alvin Kamara

 

Here's a list of QB's that have won a Superbowl while being a top 10 paid player that year:
Eli Manning

Here's a list of QB's that have won a Superbowl while not being a top 10 paid player that year:
Everyone else, including Eli Manning.

 

Is that actually true? Kinda stunning haha

 

lol i mean, there's a reason GMs and scouts are paid alright. It's kinda shown time and time again it's pretty doable to get a decent RB in the 2-5th round of drafts year in and year out.

 

Yeah I just went and looked to double check to make sure, I think Peyton was also top 10 in 2015 when they won.

So the only two were

Peyton (9th)
and Eli (10th)

 

I should've cherry picked and said top 8, damn.

 

There are only like what, 12 good starting rbs? I mean, people play fantasy football and there's plenty of teams with rbs you'd never start

 

Mahomes would net three firsts, at least, from 80% of the teams in the league. I'd do it. We can't pay him $40,000,000 / YR and win.

 

Miles Sanders
David Montgomery
Devin Singletary
Benny Snell Jr
Tony Pollard
Nick Chubb
Kerryon Johnson
Nyheim Hines
Chase Edmonds
Joe Mixon
Dalvin Cook
James Conner
Tarik Cohen
Jamaal Williams
Marlon Mack
Aaron Jones
Chris Carson

All drafted in the last three years without costing a first-round pick and you're trying to tell me it's so hard to find serviceable RBs that you have to pay a guy ~$12,474,000???

 

Fantasy football good = high volume with scoring opportunities. Receiver out of the backfield is an added plus

Actual football good = effective when you do get the ball regardless of volume, strong in pass protection and/or as a receiving threat

Those overlap but aren’t the same. And with good coaching, more guys than 12 are actual football good

 

I have a sickening addiction to arguing RBs. I need help.

 

Benny Snell, Jamaal Williams, and Tony Pollard wtf

 

Kamara isn’t a “decent” RB. You’re more likely to end up with Tevin Coleman.

 

Literally when did I say serviceable

We are talking about replacing Alvin kamara

 

lol I like Snell and when he played he looked good. I included Pollard because he looked good catching passes out of the backfield when he got his chances and since it's so impossible to replace kamara, i figured i'd need someone who can catch a pass or too. I included Jamaal Williams because if the packers are seemingly devoted to him, there must be SOMETHING good about him but like oh well on that one haha

 

And literally my entire point is you don't necessarily need to match 1:1 his production because his production is less valuable to me at 12.4 million dollars than it is at 1.2 million. I'd rather pay ~2 million for servicable than ~12 million for really good but on his second contract.

 

WR is definitely more important than TE or S

 

Yeah that's fine. The bottom ones are pretty fluid, minus RB being dead last haha

 

This will change for the Pats when the comp picks are announced. 1st and 3 3rds is enough ammo to do some things.