Hereditary wins it with 13 votes. Burning was in second place with 10 votes. Hereditary will move on to the bracket.
It's probably the most "pure horror" to win, although I'd say Videodrome and Silence of the Lambs are in the horror ballpark.
Assuming there aren't any ties in the next two, I am calling this one a tie so I can bring back Burning for the bracket.
Yeah and I have yet to even see Hereditary so that wouldn’t have made the cut. I feel like I let a lot of people down.