Manchester Orchestra's A Black Mile to the Surface wins with 26. Pop 2 had 25, and Sleep Well Beast and Melodrama tied with 22. feel like any of those three would have been more interesting winners lol.
Not saying Black Mile is a bad album, but for a year as stacked as 2017 was this is the most lackluster winner lol
that album winning isn’t surprising so much as it winning by such a narrow margin with more interesting albums so close is disappointing
Not a ton of votes in this thread, to be fair, and a lot of variety in the albums people were voting for. I'm mostly surprised Stranger in the Alps wasn't one of the top vote-getters, since Phoebe seems to be one of the 4-5 most beloved artists on this site these days.
I forgot, but I will post my list soon, because it’s good Also SweetSexySavage is the best R&B album of that decade
HYLI Vol XXII: Bathory and Mount Eerie i uhh wrote about the Mount Eerie album and my mom lol if you wanna check it out
Top 3: The Maine – Lovely Little Lonely Taylor Swift - Reputation John Mayer – The Search for Everything The Rest: Various Artists – Dirty Dancing (Original Television Soundtrack) LANY – S/T Russell Dickerson - Yours Joyner Lucas – 508-507-2209 Paramore – After Laughter Kendrick Lamar – DAMN. Aaron Carter - Love The Regrettes – Feel Your Feelings Fool! Ed Sheeran - Divide Khalid – American Teen Halsey – Hopeless Fountain Kingdom Billie Eilish – Don’t Smile at Me G-Easy – The Beautiful & Damned Amber Run – For a Moment, I Was Lost The Rocketboys – Certain Circles Brother Oliver – S/T The Unlikely Candidates – Bed of Liars Jet Black Alley Cat – Part One The Goo Goo Dolls – Boxes Eminem – Revival Grace Vanderwaal – Just the Beginning AJR – The Click Lil Uzi Vert – Luv Is Rage 2 Fifth Harmony – S/T Pvris – All We Know Of Heaven, All We Need Of Hell The Script – Freedom Child Stephen Christian – Wildfires Aly & AJ – Ten Years Rascal Flatts – Back To Us Frances – Things I've Never Said The Chainsmokers – Memories...Do Not Open Marian Hill – ACT ONE Acceptance – Colliding By Design AFI – AFI (The Blood Album) The xx – I See You SafetySuit – S/T Singles: “Malibu” – Miley Cyrus “Oh Baby” – LCD Soundsystem “IDGAF” & “Blow Your Mind (Mwah)” – Dua Lipa “Sign of the Times” – Harry Styles “Humble” & “DNA” – Kendrick Lamar “Little Bit More” – Jidenna “1-800-273-8255” – Logic “Unforgettable” – French Montana